I have casually fished Go Home Lake with limited success over the past 17 years.
I've caught pickerel, pike and smallmouth bass. The smallmouth fishing is the best. Pickerel are under a lot of pressure on this lake.
For smallmouth, worms are best but I've also consistently caught them on spinner baits as well.
There are a number of smaller back lakes connected to Go Home where the fishing is better. These you need to walk to.
Good luck!