I absolutely 100% disagree. Had he called a mayday on channel 16 the coast guard would have put out a request for help “mayday relay” We would have had coordinates. A description of the boat. How many people were on board and we would have arrived 5 - 7 minutes earlier. I wish I had a recording of the call for help. Not once did they call mayday. It certainly was not clear if the boat was sinking or if it was urgent. It eventually became clear but at that point it was already an emergency.
I believe youre right. The purpose, IMHO, of the course is to teach people in an emergency when they are under stress how to make the call with the proper info needed in a pre-scripted format..which the course teaches you..ie
Mayday Mayday Mayday
This is (boat name) Daddys Dream Daddys Dream Daddys Dream
Mayday Daddys Dream
My location is 2 miles south of Erieau (lat long coordinates if available) N42 09 40 W81 48 44
Our boat is taking on water and sinking. We have no power. We need immediate assistance from Coast Guard, fire rescue, other boats
There are 4 people on board all in life jackets
The boat is a 22 foot Sea Ray, white with a blue top
Mayday Daddies Dream
Wait 1 minute for a response, then issue again..repeat until you get a response.
Trying to remember that info in a crisis can be difficult but with training its more likely you will get the info out